{"source":{"name":"The Evidence Hub - on the regulation of digital services","url":"https:\/\/evidencehub.net","license":"Creative Common CC-BY 4.0 International"},"data":[{"data":[79.64,70.37,86.54,81.42,70.62,76.83,87.15,93.12,90.79,93.46,95.16,93.88,94.4,95,94.4,94.72,91.94,91.28],"name":"Automated flagging"},{"data":[20.36,29.63,13.46,18.58,29.38,23.17,12.85,6.88,9.21,6.54,4.84,6.12,5.6,5,5.6,5.28,8.06,8.72],"name":"Human detection"}],"_data":[["Period","Automated flagging","Human detection"],["October - December 2017","79.64%","20.36%"],["January - March 2018","70.37%","29.63%"],["April - June 2018","86.54%","13.46%"],["July - September 2018","81.42%","18.58%"],["October - December 2018","70.62%","29.38%"],["January - March 2019","76.83%","23.17%"],["April - June 2019","87.15%","12.85%"],["July - September 2019","93.12%","6.88%"],["October - December 2019","90.79%","9.21%"],["January - March 2020","93.46%","6.54%"],["April - June 2020","95.16%","4.84%"],["July - September 2020","93.88%","6.12%"],["October - December 2020","94.40%","5.60%"],["January - March 2021","95.00%","5.00%"],["April-June 2021","94.40%","5.60%"],["July-September 2021","94.72%","5.28%"],["October - December 2021","91.94%","8.06%"],["January - March 2022","91.28%","8.72%"]],"labels":{"name":"Period","values":["October - December 2017","January - March 2018","April - June 2018","July - September 2018","October - December 2018","January - March 2019","April - June 2019","July - September 2019","October - December 2019","January - March 2020","April - June 2020","July - September 2020","October - December 2020","January - March 2021","April-June 2021","July-September 2021","October - December 2021","January - March 2022"]},"metadata":{"link":"https:\/\/transparencyreport.google.com\/youtube-policy\/removals?hl=en","type":"Problem","unit":"Per cent of removed videos ","year":"2017-2022","title":"Videos Removed by YouTube, by Source of First Detection","topic":"Illegal Content","method":"Self-reporting","source":"Google. Transparency Report: YouTube Community Guidelines Enforcement (www.google.com, 2022)","sub_topic":"Prevalence of illegal content","chart_number":"124","geographical":"Global"},"description":"The chart shows the percentage of videos removed by YouTube for the period October 2017-March 2022, by first source of detection (automated flagging or human detection). Flags from human detection can come from a user or a member of YouTube\u2019s Trusted Flagger program. Trusted Flagger program members include individuals, NGOs, and government agencies that are particularly effective at notifying YouTube of content that violates their Community Guidelines. The chart shows that automated flagging is by far the first source of detection compared to human detection. "}